Categories: Politics

Supporters Predict Right-To-Work Swell If Court Rules In Hardin County’s Favor

A ruling is imminent in a federal lawsuit that will determine whether Kentucky counties are allowed to pass local right-to-work laws.

Right-to-work supporters say scores of counties in Kentucky and across the country are poised to pass local right-to-work laws if Hardin County’s law is upheld.

Jim Waters, president of the conservative think tank Bluegrass Institute, said 50 counties have requested a copy of a model right-to-work law.

“There’s just too many opportunities for counties — especially along the borders with right-to-work states like Tennessee and Indiana — there’s too many opportunities that are being lost,” Waters said.

In December, Warren County lawmakers approved a right-to-work law, which prohibits unions from forcing workers to pay dues as a condition of employment in a unionized company. Another 11 counties passed similar laws, modeled after a policy put forth by the American City County Exchange, an offshoot of the conservative think tank American Legislative Exchange Council.

Democratic Attorney General Jack Conway issued an opinion against Warren County’s policy, saying local governments lack the authority to approve right-to-work legislation.

In 1965, Shelbyville passed a right-to-work law that was later struck down by the Kentucky Court of Appeals. The appeals court ruled that the National Labor Relations Act only allows states to enact such legislation.

Right-to-work supporters argue that the policies are valid because Kentucky’s “home rule” law allows counties to pass their own economic policies. They also argue that the Supreme Court has ruled in favor of local regulatory power in cases involving pesticides and intrastate transportation.

If the judge’s ruling is favorable to Hardin County’s policy, other states that give “home rule” authority to local governments and have favorable political climates — including Ohio, Illinois and Maine — may follow suit, said James Sherk, a fellow with the Heritage Foundation.

“This could be fairly widespread in states where there’s enough support at the local level to push right-to-work, there’s not enough to get it statewide through both houses of the legislature and the governor’s signature, but there’s also not enough opposition to it that the legislature and the governor would say you can’t do this,” Sherk said.

Waters said counties have a “wait-and-see” attitude about whether to move forward with right-to-work legislation until the court provides clarity to the issue. If the court rules against the local policy, he said Kentucky supporters will renew their push on a statewide level.

The Republican-led state Senate approved a right-to-work bill in the first days of last year’s legislative session, but it was blocked in the House, which has a slim Democratic majority.

Bill Londrigan, president of the Kentucky AFL-CIO, said the House will continue to block legislation as long as Democrats have the majority. He said a handful of Republicans also oppose right-to-work laws.

“It’s a tight margin, but we have been successful in holding it, and we’re going to try to expand it with people, whether they be Republicans or Democrats, that oppose this kind of anti-union, anti-worker legislation,” Londrigan said.

Londrigan said a right-to-work law would be a gateway to other conservative policies, including a prevailing wage law and charter schools.

“It’s an incredible basket of regressive legislation that results from giving a majority status to those who are not supportive of those that work every day for a living in any real and constructive way,” Londrigan said.

Conway, who is also the Democratic candidate for governor, opposes right-to-work legislation. Republican Matt Bevin says the state “can’t afford not to pass it.”

There are 25 states with statewide right-to-work laws on the books.

Ryland Barton

Ryland Barton is the Capitol bureau chief for Kentucky Public Radio. He's covered politics and state government for NPR member stations KWBU in Waco and KUT in Austin. He has a bachelor's degree from the University of Chicago and a master's degree in journalism from the University of Texas. He grew up in Lexington.

Published by
Ryland Barton
Tags: economic developmentkentucky general assemblylabor

Recent Posts

Strange Fruit: On ‘Queen Sugar,’ Pie Is More Than Just Pie

A story line about pie sparks deeper political conversations about capitalism and appropriation.

September 22, 2018 8:00 am

Sen. Rand Paul Offers Kavanaugh Unwavering Support Amid Allegations

Paul told WKU Public Radio on Thursday evening that he thinks it’s a mistake to discredit Kavanaugh’s personal life and…

September 21, 2018 3:20 pm

Kentucky’s Diabetes Emergency Task Force Holds First Meeting

One of the issues the task force aims to address is whether Kentucky law should be changed to allow pharmacists…

September 21, 2018 3:07 pm

MSD Dumps Nearly 600 Million Gallons Of Sewage Into Ohio River During Flash Floods

The Metropolitan Sewer District estimates it discharged about 572,788,056 gallons of sewage and stormwater into the Ohio River and Beargrass Creek…

September 21, 2018 1:23 pm

Surgeon General Says Opioid Crisis Requires Fight Against Stigma

U.S. Surgeon General Jerome Adams has visited the Ohio Valley on several occasions since prioritizing the opioid crisis.

September 21, 2018 6:00 am

LISTEN: Sportswriter John Feinstein On Why The Ryder Cup Is So Important

Feinstein’s latest book is about the 2016 Ryder Cup competition between U.S. and European golfers. He’s appearing at U of…

September 20, 2018 5:40 pm