Categories: Politics

Judge Dismisses Teacher Pension Lawsuit, But Plaintiffs Will Try Again

A federal judge has dismissed a lawsuit that challenged Kentucky’s historical underfunding of the state’s teacher pension system, but the plaintiffs say they will file the lawsuit again in a state court.

The Teachers Retirement Legal Fund argues that over recent decades, state leaders broke the law by not setting aside enough money for the Kentucky Teachers Retirement System, which manages the pensions of about 141,000 current and retired teachers.

In an order issued last week, U.S. District Judge Gregory Van Tatenhove ruled that the state is protected by sovereign immunity, which shields states in most cases from being sued by individuals.

“The relief requested by the Plaintiffs is purely monetary; the effect of a judgment from this Court would be solely monetary and would force the Defendants to withdraw from the State treasury to fund KTRS,” Van Tatenhove wrote.

“This Court may not award such relief due to the sovereignty of the Commonwealth of Kentucky granted by the Eleventh Amendment.”



Kentucky legislators and governors have for nearly two decades signed off on budgets that set aside less money than necessary to keep the pension systems from losing money and selling off assets.

As the pensions systems became some of the worst-funded in the nation, Gov. Matt Bevin and the legislature passed a budget that poured an additional $1 billion into the funds.

But pension officials say the systems will need even more during the next budget cycle — a $5.4 billion total that amounts to around a quarter of the state’s already overstretched $21 billion budget.

Randy Wieck, a teacher at DuPont Manual High School in Louisville who filed the lawsuit, said the courts should force the legislature to find a way to better fund the teacher pension system.

“We’re asking the court to remind them of their duty to repair that damage that has been done,” Wieck said. “They have to have maintained an acceptable funding level, somewhere in the neighborhood of 90 percent.”

Wieck said the case could set precedent for the courts to recognize the so-called “inviolable contract,” the state’s contractual promise to honor pension benefits as they’re laid out when employees are first hired.

Bevin has promised a special legislative session later this year to make changes to the state’s pension systems.

Lawmakers have been tight-lipped about what solutions they’ll agree to, but Bevin has repeatedly pushed for shifting future state employees from defined benefit retirement plans to 401(k)-style plans.

A consulting group hired by the state recommended major changes to the pension systems by shifting future state employees to 401(k)-style plans, raising the retirement age to 65 for most state workers and clawing back cost of living adjustments given to pensioners over the last 20 years.

Ryland Barton

Ryland Barton is the Capitol bureau chief for Kentucky Public Radio. He's covered politics and state government for NPR member stations KWBU in Waco and KUT in Austin. He has a bachelor's degree from the University of Chicago and a master's degree in journalism from the University of Texas. He grew up in Lexington.

Recent Posts

Central Appalachia’s Black Lung Rates Highest In 25 Years

A new study by federal health officials finds the recent surge in cases of black lung disease is especially concentrated…

3 hours ago

Kentucky Restores Dental, Vision Insurance For Some Medicaid Recipients

The benefits roll-back initially applied to adults who became eligible for Medicaid when it was expanded, including adults without dependents…

13 hours ago

Recut: Why Is Louisville’s Eviction Rate Double The National Average?

KyCIR's Jake Ryan and Anne Marshall from Louisville Magazine went to eviction court, spoke with people facing eviction, and with…

15 hours ago

Spread Of Hepatitis A Slows In Louisville, Speeds Up Across Kentucky

While the rate of new Hepatitis A cases in Jefferson County is slowing, state and local health officials said Thursday…

18 hours ago

The Kentucky Bourbon Industry Is Worried About Long-Term Damage From A Trade War

Kentucky bourbon is in the crosshairs of retaliatory tariffs from the EU, Mexico and Canada after President Trump’s decision to…

19 hours ago

City Delays Release Of Air Quality Data For Rubbertown

Officials have delayed the release of air quality data for the neighborhoods surrounding Rubbertown, where many of the city’s industrial…

22 hours ago